Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| King-Bed Room With Private Bath -Free Wifi-- New London-Mystic |
9.6 / 10 (115 Reviews) |
From 140$ | |
| Fancy Studio Private Entrance |
9.3 / 10 (72 Reviews) |
From 105$ | |
| Riverside Retreat-Waterfront Walkout Apartment |
9.5 / 10 (82 Reviews) |
From 286$ | |
| Downtown New Haven, Spacious Stay By Yale - Ao Destinations |
8.8 / 10 (192 Reviews) |
From 117$ | |
| The Pines Men-Only Stay |
9.8 / 10 (82 Reviews) |
From 300$ |
Vacation rentals in Shelter Island offer an array of options for travelers seeking a peaceful retreat surrounded by nature. From charming cottages to luxurious waterfront homes, there is something to suit every preference and budget. This destination, known for its natural beauty and tranquil atmosphere, is ideal for families, couples, and groups looking to unwind. Explore various rental types that provide convenient access to local attractions and serene landscapes. With the right selection, your stay can be filled with comfort and memorable adventures.
Best Shelter Island Vacation Rentals
View all photos
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
View all photos
Sandpoint By Rove Travel - 6Br Family Home With Pool
View all photos
King-Bed Room With Private Bath -Free Wifi-- New London-Mystic
From 140$
View all photos
Fancy Studio Private Entrance
From 105$
View all photos
Riverside Retreat-Waterfront Walkout Apartment
From 286$
View all photos
Downtown New Haven, Spacious Stay By Yale - Ao Destinations
From 117$
View all photos
The Pines Men-Only Stay
From 300$
View all photos
Villa Signor
From 236$
View all photos
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums
From 513$
View all photos
Private Apt King Suite, L.I, Ny-Hamptons To Nyc
From 123$
View all photos
Historic Peaceful Apartment
From 123$
View all photos
New! Updated Mystic Home W/ Sauna, Hot Tub & Deck
From 310$
View all photos
Cozy Garden Apartment Along The Shoreline
From 202$
View all photos
Hyatus Luxury Residences City Crossing
From 289$
View all photos
Beautiful Studio Apartment In Historic House
From 175$
View all photos
Casa Soleada In East Rock Near Dt And Yale Som With Free Parking And King Bed
From 326$
View all photos
Historic Essex Home W/ Large Yard Near Downtown!
From 261$
View all photos
Charming Old Saybrook Cottage < 1 Mi To Beach
From 221$
View all photos
New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots!
From 309$