Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Vacation Rentals in Put-in-Bay, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #211 |
10.0 / 10 (1 Reviews) |
From 468$ | |
| Island Club Rentals |
8.1 / 10 (23 Reviews) |
From 750$ | |
| Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #207 |
9.5 / 10 (4 Reviews) |
From 555$ | |
| Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #104 |
9.7 / 10 (3 Reviews) |
From 497$ | |
| Aunt Jane'S Victorian Manor |
6.5 / 10 (4 Reviews) |
From 239$ |
Put-in-Bay, an idyllic getaway located on South Bass Island, offers an array of charming vacation rentals that cater to diverse preferences and budgets. From waterfront cottages to spacious family homes, visitors can find the perfect accommodation to enjoy the beauty of Lake Erie and the island’s rich history. Whether you’re planning a romantic retreat or an adventurous family vacation, these properties provide easy access to local attractions, including stunning parks, historical sites, and vibrant nightlife. Consider a vacation rental that suits your style, and immerse yourself in the island’s welcoming atmosphere, spectacular views, and exceptional hospitality.
Best Put-in-Bay Vacation Rentals
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #211
From 468$
An 18-minute stroll from Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo # 211 takes guests to Butterfly House Sanctuary, while Perry's Cave is a 23-minute walk away. The venue is also fitted with 1 bedroom and includes a kitchen with a microwave oven, a refrigerator, and kitchenware.
The centre of Put-in-Bay is nearly 2 km from the accommodation. You can get to South Bass Island in a few minutes by car. Toledo Express airport is only 120 km away.
View all photos
Island Club Rentals
From 750$
Island Club Rentals offers a self-catering accommodation featuring barbecue grills and a golf course. Perry's Cave Family Fun Center is accessible within 17 minutes' walk from the venue.
The villa is 2 km from the centre of Put-in-Bay and in vicinity of South Bass Island State Park. Stonehenge Estate is 2 km from this property. You can get to Perry's Cave in a few minutes by car. The nearest Toledo Express airport is 115 km from the accommodation.
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #207
From 555$
Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #207 is located 20 minutes' walk from South Bass Island Lighthouse and 18 minutes' walk away from Perry's Cave Family Fun Center. It also has 4 bedrooms as well as a kitchen which is equipped with a microwave oven, a refrigerator, and kitchenware.
The centre of Put-in-Bay is nearly 2 km from the venue. You can get to South Bass Island in a few minutes by car. This 176 m² villa is 120 km from Toledo Express airport.
Cozy Cottages on the Water
If you seek a quaint and intimate setting, the cozy waterfront cottages in Put-in-Bay may just be the ideal spot for your vacation. These charming accommodations often feature stunning lake views, private docks, and peaceful surroundings, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploration. Imagine sipping coffee on your porch while listening to the gentle lapping of waves. Many waterfront cottages come equipped with modern amenities, including full kitchens and outdoor patios, making them great options for couples and small families. Staying in one of these cottages provides direct access to boating and fishing activities, adding enjoyment to your stay.
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #104
From 497$
The self-catering Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo # 104 offers swift access to Chocolate Museum, which is about 17 minutes' walk away. There is a kitchen with a refrigerator, an oven, and kitchenware while 3 bathrooms are included as well.
The centre of Put-in-Bay is nearly 2 km from the venue. At this accommodation you'll be within an 18-minute stroll of Butterfly House Sanctuary. You can get to Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial in a few minutes by car. Toledo Express airport is placed within 120-km distance from the villa.
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Poolview Condo #6
From 253$
Put-In-Bay Poolview Condo #6 is located 18 minutes' walk from Perry's Cave and 17 minutes' walk away from Chocolate Museum. This property has a fully furnished kitchen provided with amenities, such as a microwave, a refrigerator, and kitchenware for self-catering.
The centre of Put-in-Bay is nearly 2 km from the venue. You can get to South Bass Island Lighthouse in a few minutes by car. Toledo Express airport is 120 km away.
View all photos
Put In Bay Island Club 56
From 351$
Offering a golf course and a satellite flat-screen, Put In Bay Island Club 56 Villa is situated about 20 minutes' walk from Perry's Cave. It is 5-minute drive away from Butterfly House Sanctuary.
The centre of Put-in-Bay is nearly 2 km from the venue. You can get to South Bass Island in a few minutes by car. Toledo Express airport is 115 km from this accommodation.
Spacious Family Homes
For larger groups or families, spacious homes in Put-in-Bay offer the perfect blend of comfort and entertainment. With multiple bedrooms and bathrooms, these properties provide everyone the space to relax and enjoy their time together. Many of these homes come with expansive backyards, private pools, and game rooms, ensuring there's never a dull moment. Proximity to local attractions like the Put-in-Bay Winery and various parks makes these houses ideal for creating family memories while exploring the island. After a day of adventures, you can gather around the dining table for home-cooked meals and share stories under the stars.
View all photos
Aunt Jane'S Victorian Manor
From 239$
Guests can swim in a swimming pool or be entertained during sport activities such as windsurfing, canoeing, and hiking when they stay at Aunt Jane'S Victorian Manor Villa. With a stay at this venue, you'll be 1.2 km from Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial.
Local attractions include South Bass Island steps away from the accommodation and city centre 1 km away. You can easily get to Butterfly House Sanctuary which is 0.9 km away. Relax with a refreshing drink at bar Reel Bar within 300 metres from the property. You can get to South Bass Island Lighthouse in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is Toledo Express located within 120 km from Aunt Jane'S Victorian Manor Villa.
View all photos
Island Club #93
From 585$
The 1-bedroom Island Club # 93 Venue is less than merely 1.8 km from Perry's Cave. This accommodation also comes with a fully furnished kitchen complete with a microwave, a refrigerator, and kitchenware, so you can easily make your favourite dishes.
Chocolate Museum lies within a 20-minute walk of the villa. The property is 2 km from the centre of Put-in-Bay. You can get to South Bass Island Lighthouse in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is Toledo Express airport, 120 km from Island Club # 93 Venue.
View all photos
Cozy Middle Bass Cabin With Grill And Lagoon Access!
From 189$
The 2-bedroom Cozy Middle Bass Cabin With Grill And Lagoon Access! Venue is less than merely 400 metres from the quieter Middle Bass Island. Guests, staying at this accommodation, can use a kitchen with a microwave, a refrigerator, and a cooktop to prepare home-cooked meals.
The villa is 3 km from the centre of Put-in-Bay and in vicinity of Bass Islands. The property is approximately 10 minutes' drive from South Bass Island Lighthouse. This venue is also set close to Lonz Winery. You can get to Perry's Cave in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is Toledo Express, 125 km from Cozy Middle Bass Cabin With Grill And Lagoon Access! Accommodation.
Charming Bed and Breakfasts
Put-in-Bay is home to several delightful bed and breakfasts that offer a unique take on vacation rentals. These quaint establishments often feature beautifully decorated rooms with personalized touches that enhance your stay. Guests can enjoy a hearty breakfast every morning, setting the tone for a day filled with island exploration. Many bed and breakfasts are conveniently located near local shops and eateries, allowing easy access to everything Put-in-Bay has to offer. These intimate accommodations provide a warm ambiance, making them ideal for couples looking for a romantic getaway.
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Island Club #71
From 1345$
Island Club # 71 Venue is situated 5 minutes' drive from Chocolate Museum in Put-in-Bay and offers accommodation with a kitchen. This 1-bedroom property includes a swimming pool and a terrace.
South Bass Island Lighthouse lies within a 14-minute walk of the villa. Put-in-Bay city centre is approximately 2 km away. You can get to Butterfly House Sanctuary in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is Toledo Express, 115 km away from the venue.
View all photos
Island Club #105
From 556$
Located in Put-in-Bay, 1-bedroom Island Club # 105 Venue measures 111 m² and can accommodate 10 guests. With a stay at this accommodation, you'll be 1 km from South Bass Island Lighthouse.
Toledo Express airpot is 115 km from the villa, while Chocolate Museum is merely 1.5 km away. The centre of Put-in-Bay is 2 km away from the property. You can get to the battle monument "Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial" in a few minutes by car. Lime Kiln Dock bus station can be reached within 15 minutes' walk from this venue.
View all photos
Resort-Style Condo With Lake-View Balcony!
From 413$
Resort-Style Condo With Lake-View Balcony! venue is a spacious apartment located in vicinity of Middle Bass Island. The accommodation includes 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and a fully equipped kitchen.
North Bass Island is 4 km from this property while Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial is 2.6 km away. It is 3 km away from the city centre of Put-in-Bay. This cosy accommodation lies close to Lake Erie. The venue is nestled within a short taxi ride from Cave. Toledo Express airport is set 125 km from the apartment.
Luxurious Lakeview Suites
For those desiring a touch of elegance, the luxurious lakeview suites in Put-in-Bay provide a lavish escape. Featuring stunning panoramic views of Lake Erie, these well-appointed accommodations often include modern furnishings, spa-like bathrooms, and private balconies. Unwind in style and comfort, with amenities such as hot tubs and gourmet kitchens at your disposal. The proximity to upscale dining options and picturesque beaches allows guests to enjoy a lavish experience while still embracing the charm of the island. A stay in these suites promises relaxation and sophistication.
View all photos
Cozy Lakefront Middle Bass Retreat W/ Balcony
From 414$
Cozy Lakefront Middle Bass Retreat With Balcony Apartment is located about 30-minute walk away from the centre of Put-in-Bay and offers spacious accommodation with a view of the lake. Featuring a fully-fitted kitchen, the venue is only 0.7 km from Lonz Winery.
The scenic park "Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial" is located 2.6 km from the apartment. Perry's Cave is a short taxi ride away. The nearest airport is Toledo Express, set 125 km from this property.
View all photos
Middle Bass Condo W/ Balcony, Lake Erie Views
From 258$
Middle Bass Condo With Balcony, Lake Erie Views offers spacious accommodation, set within 30 minutes' walk of Put-in-Bay city centre. Placed 4.5 km from South Bass Island State Park, the property consists of 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and a fully-fitted kitchen.
The accommodation is placed within a 10-minute drive from North Bass Island. You can get to South Bass Island Lighthouse in a couple of minutes by car. This 77 m² apartment is 125 km from the Toledo Express airport.
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #107
From 819$
Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo # 107 is situated about 10 minutes' drive from Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial in Put-in-Bay and offers accommodation with a kitchen. The property comprises 1 bedroom and 3 bathrooms.
The centre of Put-in-Bay is nearly 2 km from the venue. At this villa you'll be within an 18-minute stroll of Perry's Cave Family Fun Center. You can get to South Bass Island Lighthouse in a few minutes by car. Toledo Express airport is 120 km away from Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo # 107.
Budget-Friendly Apartments
Travelers on a budget will find several economical apartments available for rent in Put-in-Bay. These budget-friendly options offer everything needed for a comfortable stay without the financial strain. Many apartments come equipped with kitchenettes, allowing guests to prepare their own meals and save on dining out. Conveniently located within walking distance of key attractions, these rentals allow guests to explore the island without the need for a car. With efficient layouts and community amenities, budget-conscious travelers can still enjoy all the island has to offer.
View all photos
Put-In-Bay Poolview Condo #8
From 253$
Put-In-Bay Poolview Condo # 8 is situated 17 minutes' stroll from Butterfly House Sanctuary in Put-in-Bay and offers accommodation with a kitchen. 1 bedroom and 2 bathrooms are comprised in this venue.
Perry's Cave lies within an 18-minute walk of the property. Guests can get to Put-in-Bay city centre in 15 minutes on foot. You can get to Chocolate Museum in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is Toledo Express, 120 km away from the villa.
Quaint Historic Homes
Embrace the charming history of Put-in-Bay by choosing to stay in one of the quaint historic homes available for rent. These properties are often rich in character and have been lovingly restored while maintaining their original architectural charm. With access to local landmarks and historical sites, these homes allow guests to immerse themselves in the island’s past. Enjoy cozy living spaces complemented by modern comforts, making your stay both memorable and enjoyable. Staying in a historic home offers a unique opportunity to connect with the island’s heritage while surrounded by contemporary amenities.
Pet-Friendly Rentals
For visitors wishing to bring along their furry companions, Put-in-Bay offers a selection of pet-friendly vacation rentals. These properties ensure that no member of the family is left behind, allowing pets to enjoy the island's fresh air and scenic surroundings. Many of these rentals feature easy access to outdoor spaces where pets can play and explore. Whether you seek a cozy cottage or a spacious home, you can find accommodations that cater to both your needs and those of your four-legged friends. Enjoy the adventures of Put-in-Bay together, creating lasting memories with your loved ones.