Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Vacation Rentals in New Buffalo, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Anchors Away |
7.1 / 10 (11 Reviews) |
From 221$ | |
| Square Toe'S Last Resort |
9.7 / 10 (11 Reviews) |
From 716$ | |
| Hydrangea House |
8.4 / 10 (9 Reviews) |
From 500$ | |
| Walking Distance To Beach And Shops |
8.6 / 10 (47 Reviews) |
From 424$ | |
| Eagles Beach Nest II |
9.3 / 10 (16 Reviews) |
From 954$ |
New Buffalo offers a charming selection of vacation rentals suited for diverse tastes and budgets. Whether you are looking for a cozy cottage by the beach, a modern apartment downtown, or a spacious family home, you'll find numerous options to enhance your stay. With its scenic waterfront, vibrant local culture, and a variety of outdoor activities, New Buffalo is an ideal destination for relaxation and enjoyment. Families, couples, and solo travelers alike can enjoy the comfort and convenience of local rentals while exploring this picturesque lakeside community.
Best New Buffalo Vacation Rentals
View all photos
Anchors Away
From 221$
Anchors Away Villa is situated around 10 minutes' drive from Blueberries Of Indiana in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-equipped kitchen. 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms can be found at this venue.
Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina is approximately 5 minutes' drive away. The centre of New Buffalo is a 20-minute walk away. You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional, 55 km away from the villa.
View all photos
Square Toe'S Last Resort
From 716$
Square Toe'S Last Resort is situated merely 350 metres from Saint Mary of the Lake Church in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully furnished kitchen. The venue offers Wi-Fi available throughout the villa.
The property is 1 km from the centre of New Buffalo and in vicinity of Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina. It is a 53-minute drive from South Bend Regional airport and a 5-minute drive to Whittaker Woods Golf Course. The nearest restaurants including Promeny Olive & Wine and Oink's Dutch Treat are 500 metres away. You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Hydrangea House
From 500$
Hydrangea House Villa is situated 6 minutes on foot from New Buffalo Township Library in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-equipped kitchen. This venue has 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
The property is 1 km from the centre of New Buffalo and in vicinity of Barney's. Also, you'll be 2.7 km from Whittaker Woods Golf Course. Quench your thirst with your favourite drink at the dessert restaurant Oink's Dutch Treat within 6 minutes' walk from Hydrangea House Villa. Warner Vineyards Tasting Room is located nearby. From South Bend Regional airport, the villa is a 53-minutes drive away.
View all photos
Coastal Escape
Coastal Escape Villa is situated around 10 minutes by car from Blueberries Of Indiana in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-equipped kitchen. Guests can take a dip in a private pool followed by relaxing with a hot tub.
The venue is 5 minutes' drive from Whittaker Woods Golf Course. The centre of New Buffalo is a 20-minute walk away. There are several restaurants in the surroundings, including Rios Mexican Grill #1 and I CAN Cafe. You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car. The villa is located in a 56-minute drive from South Bend Regional airport.
View all photos
Walking Distance To Beach And Shops
From 424$
Walking Distance To Beach And Shops Villa is located less than within 700 metres of New Buffalo Township Library and has a play area and a garden. It is composed of 1 bedroom, a fully furnished kitchen and 1 bathroom.
The venue is 1 km from the centre of New Buffalo and in vicinity of Barney's. At this property you'll be within a 20-minute stroll of New Buffalo Railroad Museum. Guests can try American meals in the barbecue New Buffalo Bill's Wood Fired Bbq located 50 metres away. You can get to Whittaker Woods Golf Course in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional airport, 55 km from Walking Distance To Beach And Shops Villa.
View all photos
Eagles Beach Nest II
From 954$
Eagles Beach Nest II Villa is situated about 25 minutes' walk from Whittaker Woods Golf Course in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-equipped kitchen. Guests staying at this venue have access to Wi-Fi throughout the villa.
The property is 1 km from the centre of New Buffalo and in vicinity of the full-service Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina. Also, you'll be 1.1 km from New Buffalo Township Library. Promeny Olive & Wine is 300 metres from Eagles Beach Nest II Villa. Saint Mary of the Lake Church is located nearby. From South Bend Regional airport, the venue is a 53-minutes drive away.
View all photos
The Shore House By Juniper Holiday + Home
The Shore House Villa is situated 2.5 km from Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-equipped kitchen. 5 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms can be found at this venue.
New Buffalo Township Library is approximately 10 minutes' drive away. The centre of New Buffalo is about 30 minutes' walk away. You can get to Galien River County Nature Park in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional, 55 km away from the villa.
View all photos
Eagle'S Beach Nest
From 539$
Eagle'S Beach Nest Villa is situated about 10 minutes by car from Blueberries Of Indiana in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully equipped kitchen. The venue features a patio.
The villa is 1 km from the centre of New Buffalo and in vicinity of the full-service Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina. Within a 1.1-km distance you will find Barney's. Guests can dine in the quick bites Rios Mexican Food located just 250 metres away. Popular points of interest near this property include Saint Mary of the Lake Church. The venue is a 53-minute drive from South Bend Regional airport.
View all photos
Schoolhouse Rock By Juniper Holiday + Home
Schoolhouse Rock Villa is situated merely 0.8 km from Third Coast Surf Shop in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-equipped kitchen. The venue is composed of 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
Local attractions include New Buffalo Railroad Museum steps away from the villa and city centre 1 km away. First United Methodist is 0.8 km away and South Bend Regional airport is 55 km from the property. At Brewster's Italian Cafe and David's Delicatessen you can enjoy wide gastronomic offer of an Italian cuisine, 650 metres away from the venue. You can get to Galien River County Nature Park in a few minutes by car. The airport is 53 minutes drive away.
View all photos
Charming New Buffalo Condo: Walk To Lake Michigan!
From 260$
Charming New Buffalo Condo Walk To Lake Michigan! is a spacious venue located in New Buffalo within 5 minutes' walk of New Buffalo Township Library. This apartment is steps away from Barney's and it also provides an oven and a stovetop in a full kitchen.
The accommodation is 8 minutes’ walk from New Buffalo Beach. The property is situated near a public beach, 1 km from the centre of New Buffalo. Nearby Terrace Room and Beachside Scoops can be reached within 5 minutes on foot. Galien River County Nature Park is a short taxi ride away. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional airport, 55 km from this welcoming venue in New Buffalo.
View all photos
The Oasis At Forest Beach
The Oasis At Forest Beach Villa offers an accommodation within 56 minutes by car from South Bend Regional airport. The venue offers a hot tub.
The villa is set a 10-minute ride from New Buffalo Railroad Museum and 3.7 km from Blueberries Of Indiana. The centre of New Buffalo is about 3 km away. You can get to Whittaker Woods Golf Course in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Livywood Cottage
From 143$
Livywood Cottage is situated about 10 minutes by car from Blueberries Of Indiana in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a fully-fitted kitchen. This villa has 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
New Buffalo Railroad Museum is approximately 15 minutes' drive away. You can get to Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional located within 60 km from Livywood Cottage.
View all photos
Nothin Dune
From 4261$
Nothin Dune Villa is set nearly 25 minutes' walk from Barney's and represents a 3-bedroom venue with a patio. Leisure facilities include a hot tub offered on-site.
Guests will appreciate a beachfront location a 25-minute walk away from New Buffalo city centre. Galien River County Park is 15 minutes’ drive from accommodation. You can get to Blueberries Of Indiana in a few minutes by car. Nothin Dune Villa is located about 58 minutes by car from South Bend Regional airport.
View all photos
The Tree House
From 572$
The Tree House Villa is situated approximately 20 minutes' walk from Barney's in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a full kitchen. Guests can indulge in a hot tub offered on the premises.
The venue is 5 minutes' drive from New Buffalo Railroad Museum. The centre of New Buffalo is approximately 15 minutes’ walk away. I CAN Cafe and Rios Mexican Grill # 1 are set 650 metres away from the property. You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car. South Bend Regional airport is a 56-minute drive from The Tree House Villa.
View all photos
Wild Horse Run By Juniper Holiday + Home
Wild Horse Run Villa is located 25 minutes' walk from Saint Mary of the Lake Church and 16 minutes' walk away from Third Coast Surf Shop. A hot tub are offered for relaxation.
The centre of New Buffalo is nearly 1 km from the venue. The barbecue New Buffalo Bill's Wood Fired Bbq is situated 500 metres of the accommodation. You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car. South Bend Regional airport is 55 km from this villa.
View all photos
Marquette Cottage
A 14-minute stroll from Marquette Cottage takes guests to Barney's, while New Buffalo Railroad Museum is a 25-minute walk away. It offers a beachfront accommodation including a private swimming pool.
New Buffalo Bill's Wood Fired Bbq is a barbecue that offers a variety of American meals. You can get to Galien River County Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
The Songbird By Juniper Holiday + Home
From 520$
The 2-bedroom Songbird Villa is less than approximately 4 km from New Buffalo Railroad Museum. It includes a full kitchen and 2 bathrooms.
The centre of New Buffalo is nearly 4 km from the venue. Antique Mall of Union Pier is a 10-minute car ride away. You can get to the full - service Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional, situated 55 km from the accommodation.
View all photos
Eagles Nest
From 734$
Eagles Nest Villa is set a 10-minute ride from Whittaker Woods Golf Course and represents a 3-bedroom venue with a patio. You can relax with a sauna available on site.
Ambler Flatwoods Nature Preserve is approximately 10 minutes' drive away. You can get to New Buffalo Railroad Museum in a few minutes by car. The nearest airport is South Bend Regional, 60 km away from the accommodation.
View all photos
Magnolia Place
From 346$
Magnolia Place Villa offers an accommodation within 56 minutes by car from South Bend Regional airport. 2 bathrooms, 2 bedrooms and a full kitchen are provided on the premises.
New Buffalo Railroad Museum is around 6 km away, while Blueberries Of Indiana is 4.5 km from the venue. You can get to Ambler Flatwoods Nature Preserve in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
The Sands
From 336$
The Sands Villa is set 2.8 km from Four Winds Casino New Buffalo and represents a 2-bedroom venue with a patio. The accommodation comes with 2 bathrooms and a fully furnished kitchen.
The centre of New Buffalo is nearly 1 km from the property. You'll be steps from Barney's and 1.3 km from Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina. Quench your thirst with your favourite drink at the pizzeria Brewster's Italian Cafe within 7 minutes' walk from The Sands Villa. New Buffalo Farmers Market is located nearby. South Bend Regional airport is based 55 km away.
View all photos
Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard
Blocks To Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard is situated 20 minutes on foot from New Buffalo Township Library in New Buffalo and offers accommodation with a kitchen. This property has 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
Whittaker Woods Golf Course is approximately 5 minutes' drive away. The walk to the centre of New Buffalo will last for 15 minutes. The café I CAN Cafe is about 550 metres away. You can get to Barney's in a few minutes by car. The villa is located in a 56-minute drive from South Bend Regional airport.