Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Vacation Rentals in Kelleys Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Walk To Lake Erie Renovated 2Br Huron Home Near Cedar Point & Kalahari |
9.7 / 10 (18 Reviews) |
From 89$ | |
| Millsite Lodge |
9.8 / 10 (23 Reviews) |
From 160$ | |
| Home Steps From Oberlin |
9.2 / 10 (18 Reviews) |
From 124$ | |
| Lakewood Home W/ Yard ~ 8 Mi To Cleveland! |
9.4 / 10 (10 Reviews) |
From 140$ | |
| Cozy Tiffin House W/ Private Pool: 1 Mi To Town! |
9.8 / 10 (7 Reviews) |
From 125$ |
Kelleys Island is a unique vacation spot situated in the heart of Lake Erie, offering an array of vacation rentals perfect for families, couples, and solo travelers alike. With its picturesque landscapes and delightful summer activities, the island provides various accommodations that meet diverse needs and preferences. From cozy cabins to modern lakeside homes, there's something available for everyone. Plan your retreat and make the most of your stay by exploring the options that Kelleys Island has to offer.
Best Kelleys Island Vacation Rentals
View all photos
Beck Lake House
View all photos
On Island Time At Kelleys Island Condo!
View all photos
New! Kelleys Island Condo
View all photos
Large Family Gathering Home On Kelleys Island
View all photos
Walk To Lake Erie Renovated 2Br Huron Home Near Cedar Point & Kalahari
From 89$
View all photos
Millsite Lodge
From 160$
View all photos
Home Steps From Oberlin
From 124$
View all photos
Lakewood Home W/ Yard ~ 8 Mi To Cleveland!
From 140$
View all photos
Cozy Tiffin House W/ Private Pool: 1 Mi To Town!
From 125$
View all photos
The Shores Condo W/ Beach Access < 2 Mi To Dtwn!
From 118$
View all photos
Small Suite Steps From Oberlin
From 126$
View all photos
Home W/ Lake-View Deck By Camp Perry & Magee Marsh
From 242$
View all photos
Marlin At The Lake - Downtown Sandusky
From 112$
View all photos
Great Wolf Lodge Sandusky
From 285$
View all photos
Harborview 3-6-8 On Main
From 278$
View all photos
Waterfront Sandusky Vacation Rental: Downtown!
From 345$